39 Best Shaving Creams for Sensitive Skin

20

There is nothing quite like a nice, fresh shave. You’re left looking and feeling clean, and smelling great. Whether you’re shaving your face, your legs, your armpits or anywhere else, you need the right shaving cream for the job. This is especially important if you have sensitive skin.

Most traditional shaving creams won’t cut it. They contain harsh chemicals that irritate your skin, and can lead to razor burn, itchiness, cuts and nicks.

That’s why we’ve developed this list of the 39 best shaving creams for sensitive skin. These contain skin-safe, natural ingredients that soothe irritated skin, and they work well for both men and women. You’ll enjoy a close, comfortable shave every time with these products. If you’re tired of distressed skin after shaving, read on.

What Are the Best Shaving Creams for Sensitive Skin?

In our list of the 39 best shaving creams for sensitive skin, you’re going to see a lot of great products. We felt it was important to provide a diverse selection because we know everyone has different needs and preferences. We worked hard to vet these products and curate the best of the best, and we’re confident we have done so with this list. That means you can browse below and pick your favorite knowing you’re getting the best bang for your buck.

Are all 39 of these shaving creams created equal? Not necessarily. After all, only one can truly be the best. That’s why we’ve placed the Blu Atlas Natural Shaving Cream at the top of our list. Keep reading to discover what makes it so special, and why you need it in your shaving regimen.

1. Blu Atlas Shaving Cream

There is no doubt in our mind that Blu Atlas Shaving Cream is the No. 1 choice for sensitive skin. The safe, natural ingredients have soothing properties that create a close, comfortable shave. Though this product is designed for men, women have discovered its gentle power and many have incorporated it into their grooming routine.

The formula is designed to reduce inflammation and prevent nicks and cuts with ingredients like coco-caprylate and tocopheryl acetate. These ingredients also help promote overall skin health and diminish the signs of aging. The only feeling better than shaving with this product? Putting on the fragrant, ultra-soothing Blu Atlas After Shave once you’re finished! This product is 100% vegan, natural, and made in NYC. It even comes with a 100% money-back guarantee, so you’ve literally got nothing to lose by trying it out yourself.

2. Jack Black Beard Lube

One of the most versatile, well-rounded products on this list is the Jack Black Beard Lube. This translucent formula goes above and beyond, functioning as a pre-shave oil, shave cream and an aftershave conditioner all in one. It softens your facial hair and prepares it for a smooth, pain-free shave. Ingredients include macadamia nut oil, jojoba oil, glycerin, phospholipids, peppermint, eucalyptus and menthol, which work in synergy to promote soft, supple skin and fend off irritation. If you want one product that does it all, you can’t go wrong with this lube from Jack Black.

3. Lab Series Cooling Shaving Cream

The Lab Series Cooling Shaving Cream claims to offer the most sophisticated shave yet. It features an ultra-rich formulation that refreshes your skin and leaves it in a complete state of bliss – cool, calm and nick-free. It cushions against razor burn and bumps and invigorates your skin, all at the same time.

One of the things we love most about this sensitive-skin-approved shaving cream is the environmentally friendly, sustainable packaging it comes in. While it’s rated for all skin types, this cream is best for sensitive skin.

4. Paul Mitchell Shave Detailer

You’ve no doubt heard of the brand Paul Mitchell. You may have even used some of their products. This renowned company’s Shave Detailer is another product to consider in your quest for the finest shaving cream for your sensitive skin. It allows you to get an ultra-close shave that leaves your skin silky smooth. Made with barley seed oil, macadamia seed oil and other natural ingredients, it will help you achieve a seamless razor glide.

5. Tree Hut Bare Moisturizing Shave Gel

If you find that most shaving gels leave your skin dry and itchy, consider the Tree Hut Bare Moisturizing Shave Gel. This hydrating formula helps you unlock a close, comfortable shave free of stubble, nicks and bumps. It’s time to say hello to beautiful skin, coupled with the delicious, skin-quenching scent of watermelon, lemon zest and raspberry cotton candy. This one is aimed primarily at women.

6. Nivea Men Sensitive Shaving Gel

We love Nivea for their moisturizing products, but their Sensitive Shaving Gel is another formulation that exceeds expectations. It offers moisturizing and soothing benefits while helping protect the skin from irritation while shaving.

This is all thanks to Nivea’s Ultra Glide Technology, featuring chamomile extract, witch hazel and more. The gel is dermatologically tested by men with sensitive skin, so you can rest assured it’s safe. The product contains no alcohol whatsoever, just natural, skin-loving goodness.

7. Acqua di Parma Soft Shaving Cream

Another excellent shaving cream if you have sensitive skin is this product by Acqua di Parma. Their formula is ultra-hydrating and creamy, softening skin and raising hair strands to allow for a close, comfortable shave every time. When you order from the brand’s website, you get free shipping on every order, and free samples to boot. You might just find your new favorite grooming product in those free samples!

8. Fur Shave Cream

Fur Shave Cream is a proven formula that can be used for shaving any part of the body. It has been clinically proven to fight against bumps, razor burn and irritation, while leaving your skin soft and moisturized. The cream is featherlight and cruelty-free.

It contains powerhouse ingredients like olive oil, aloe and marshmallow root extract, as well as coconut-derived moisturizing agents. It’s completely free of parabens, silicones, phthalates, artificial colors and fragrances.

9. Art of Shaving Unscented Shaving Cream

Many of us love shaving cream with a fragrance. Not only does it make the shaving experience more enjoyable, but it also leaves your skin smelling incredible. However, we know many of our readers are seeking an unscented formula for their extra-sensitive skin. Some fragrances can do more harm than good, after all. That’s where the Art of Shaving Unscented Shaving Cream comes in.

This formula forms a thick, protective lather for shaving safely and comfortably. It leaves your skin hydrated and soft. You can shave in confidence with this one as it’s clinically and dermatologically tested for sensitive skin.

10. Truefitt & Hill Shaving Cream

Resembling a product your great-great-grandpa used to use, this remarkably effective shaving cream by Truefitt & Hill is worth considering if you have sensitive skin. And the reality is, your great-great-grandparents could very well have used this product, as Truefitt & Hill have been in the game since 1805! This formula is ultra-hydrating, with a blend of rare, natural and sophisticated ingredients. You’ll love the fragrance notes of geranium, clary sage, lavender, mandarin and bergamot.

11. Eos Shea Butter Shave Cream

Eos Shea Butter Shave Cream is perhaps the most affordable option on this list. It’s available in a wide range of delicious, fragrant scents like pink citrus, lavender, vanilla bliss and even pomegranate raspberry. With moisturizing shea oil and shea butter, this shave and shower lotion works wonders to provide 24-hour hydration. It will help you get your softest, smoothest, closest shave ever. It’s paraben-free, phthalate-free and gluten-free, so you can’t go wrong with this product.

12. Aveeno Therapeutic Shave Gel

This Aveeno Therapeutic Shave Gel is as soothing and relaxing as it gets, and is suitable for both men and women. It contains oatmeal and vitamin E to protect the skin against razor bumps, and is fortified with moisturizing lubricants to help you get a tight shave without nicks and cuts. Your skin is left hydrated and soothed after each shave. This product is formulated specifically for men and women with dry, sensitive skin.

13. Coochy Plus Intimate Shaving Cream

As the name suggests, Coochy Plus Intimate Shaving Cream is designed to be soft and gentle enough for even the most intimate areas of your body. Shaving down there can be daunting, but you can shave in confidence using this moisturizing, protecting cream. It’s formulated with potent plant-based ingredients like jojoba oil, avocado oil, aloe vera, shea butter and maca root.

These provide anti-inflammatory and lubricating effects, along with a host of essential vitamins. It’s safe for all skin types but works especially well for those with sensitive skin. And while it’s geared toward female readers, this product is also suitable for men who shave their body hair.

14. Marlow No. 141 Shave Cream

Featuring moisturizing coconut oil and shea butter, Marlow No. 141 Shave Cream helps soothe skin while forming a barrier that protects and preps for a close shave. It also features willow bark extract for further protection.

Suited for all skin types, this incredible product is paraben- and phthalate-free, never tested on animals, and made right here in the United States. You can get free shipping on orders over $25 to help you stretch your budget further!

15. Billie Shave Cream

We love Billie Shave Cream because you can get it quickly and easily; in fact, it’s available through Walmart! If you’re in a time crunch and don’t want to wait for shipping, this might be the perfect pick. This is one of the most effective of the budget shaving creams.

The award-winning formula features shea butter, coconut oil, aloe vera and a fresh lavender and bergamot fragrance. It forms the perfect barrier between your skin and your razor, leaving you free of irritation and with velvety skin. It’s vegan, cruelty-free, paraben-free, sulfate-free and aerosol-free.

16. Clinique for Men Shave Cream

Clinique for Men Shave Cream is a super-rich lathering formula that every man will appreciate, especially those with sensitive skin. It will leave your skin feeling sleek, smooth and comfortable. This product is fairly basic, but it works well. Clinique is a tried-and-tested brand, and one many customers feel safe with.

17. Gillette Satin Care Ultra Sensitive Shave Gel

Gillette Satin Care Ultra Sensitive Shave Gel is exactly what it sounds like – a shave gel designed for those whose skin is easily irritated. It’s free of common skin irritants like dyes so you can get the close, comfortable shave you want without aggravating your skin. It’s dermatologically tested to leave your skin comfortable and smooth, and fragrant with natural eucalyptus and lavender scent.

18. Claus Porto Shaving Cream

This practical, effective shaving cream by Claus Porto was a no-brainer addition to our list of the best shaving creams for sensitive skin. It’s enriched with lanolin and other natural oils that soften your facial hair and prepare it for a close shave.

You will experience no pulling or tugging on hair that can cause irritation and razor burn. Your skin will be left swift, soothed and replenished. It will also smell great, thanks to subtle notes of patchouli, bergamot, vetiver, musk and lavender.

19. Pacific Shaving Company Natural Shaving Cream

This top-selling formula from Pacific Shaving Company features safe, natural, plant-based ingredients like aloe, sunflower seed oil, shea butter and a whole host of fragrant, skin-loving essential oils. You can start enjoying shaving again knowing razor burn and irritation are a thing of the past.

Redness, razor bumps and dry skin will no longer be an issue, as these certified organic ingredients work to leave your skin healthy, soothed and hydrated. This cruelty-free formula is made right here in the USA.

20. Le Labo Shaving Cream

Le Labo Shaving Cream is a classic formula that any seasoned man will enjoy incorporating into his shaving regimen. The plant-based formula features powerhouse ingredients like chamomile, sage and coconut, which work together to tone, nourish and soothe even the most delicate skin.

You’ll be in awe as your razor glides effortlessly across your skin, achieving a close, comfortable cut. The product is free from parabens, phthalates and artificial colors, and has a soothing fragrance derived from bergamot, lavender, violet, and tonka bean. We absolutely love this classic shaving cream.

21. Gillette Series Shaving Gel Sensitive Skin

No list of the best shaving creams would be complete without at least one appearance by Gillette. This brand is a giant in the shaving cream industry, and the Shaving Gel Sensitive Skin Pack they offer is perhaps the best bargain buy on this list. You can stock up with six cans and get unbeatable savings!

This formula is gentle and effective. It hydrates, protects and soothes skin with ingredients like aloe. And it’s lightly scented with natural fragrance, further protecting from irritation.

22. Proraso Sensitive Skin Shave Cream

This Italian shaving cream by Proraso offers a rich, creamy lather that prepares your skin for a close shave without unsightly razor burn. It features skin-safe natural ingredients like green tea and oatmeal that soothe and protect your skin. Light hints of lime and apple refresh but aren’t overpowering. This cream is free from animal ingredients, parabens, silicones, mineral oils, artificial colors, SLS and phthalates. Ninety percent of the ingredients are of natural origin.

23. Harry’s Shave Cream

A proper shave requires the right foundation, and this rich, conditioning formula by Harry’s provides just that. It hydrates and softens your beard for a closer, more comfortable shave. With soothing, cooling essential oils like eucalyptus and mint, the sensations you’ll feel when shaving with this one will assure you that you made the right choice. It features aloe vera and a dozen other natural oils and extracts to further soften and soothe your skin after each shave.

24. Kiehl’s Close Shavers Lotion

Kiehl’s is one of the industry leaders in men’s grooming and personal care. So it should come as no surprise that we’re featuring their Close Shavers Lotion on our list. This precisely crafted formula helps you get an ultra-close shave.

Formulated to be safe for all skin types, including sensitive skin, this lightweight lotion prepares your skin with protecting ingredients and leaves it ultra-soft. It also smells amazing, as the lotion is infused with eucalyptus oil. This paraben-free formula is a good option to test out if you’re still not sure which product is right for you.

25. Taylor of Old Bond Street Natural Shaving Cream

Perhaps the most unique luxury shaving cream we’ve come across is this one by Taylor of Old Bond Street. Their classic formula offers a citrus, aromatic and woody fragrance that you will love. But it’s not just about the scent – the formula is crafted for sensitive skin, with organic ingredients like aloe and jojoba oil. It’s gentle on your skin and free from ingredients like fragrance, paraben and preservatives.

26. Bee Bald Shave Cream

Are you tired of nicks and cuts while shaving? It’s time to face the truth: Your razor is not to blame! The problem is with your shaving cream. And if you want to make this a concern of the past, try out Bee Bald Shave Cream.

It’s incredibly smooth and quick, and great for all skin types. While it’s designed for men in particular, women love the formulation as well. It will leave your skin feeling fresh and revitalized, with just a small dollop going a long way. This is the brand’s top seller, and we can see why.

27. Bevel Shave System Cream

Bevel Shave System Cream is a unique, water-free formula that we just had to include on this list. It’s formulated with aloe vera, shea butter, green tea, witch hazel extract, coconut water and comfrey extract to form an ultra-soothing and moisturizing lather.

It helps your razor glide effortlessly over your skin, making fine, precise cuts. It will leave you free of irritation and razor bumps, never tugging or nicking. This dermatologist-tested product is also nourishing, leaving your skin healthier than ever before.

28. Cremo Cooling Shave Cream

Looking to fight razor burn? This crisp, refreshing and cooling shave cream by Cremo is just what you need. It contains a lively blend of essential oils like peppermint, tea tree and menthol.

These work in synergy to leave your skin in a state of complete bliss, while protecting against irritation associated with shaving. The razor will glide with unbelievable ease so you can enjoy a close, comfortable shave every time. Your skin will be left astonishingly smooth and deliciously fragrant.

29. Neutrogena Men Shave Cream

Neutrogena Men Shave Cream is an excellent budget-friendly option for those with sensitive skin. The cream is formulated to protect the delicate skin on the face, helping men who shave daily to avoid raw, irritated skin.

It utilizes Pro-Soothe Technology, which provides unparalleled protection against razor burn and ingrown hairs. Neutrogena Men Shave Cream is non-comedogenic and dye-free, so you can shave in complete confidence. After all, Neutrogena is rated No. 1 men’s skin-care brand by most experts!

30. Vanicream Shave Cream

Vanicream Shave Cream helps you achieve a close, comfortable shave across your entire body. It creates a protective barrier between your razor and skin to eliminate concerns surrounding razor burn, nicks and cuts.

It rinses off clean and easy to reveal perfectly shaved and conditioned skin that is smooth to the touch. It’s also free of potential irritants like dyes, fragrances, parabens, gluten, alcohol and botanical extracts. Just what you need for a hydrating, comfortable shave.

31. Schaf Shave Cream

This soothing shave cream by Schaf helps comfort your skin while preventing nicks and cuts along the way. You’ll enjoy irritation-free, razor burn-free and cut-free skin with each shave. In fact, you may find that you finally enjoy shaving for the first time in your life!

This award-winning formula features some of our favorite skin-safe ingredients, like coconut oil, aloe vera and hyaluronic acid. These all work to condition your skin while other ingredients protect your skin during the shave. This product is 100% natural and comes with a money-back guarantee.

32. Flamingo Foaming Shave Gel

Flamingo Foaming Shave Gel might look like it’s just for the ladies, but this one works great for any gender and skin type. The luxury gel cushions your skin and provides a barrier from your razor to achieve a close, comfortable shave every time.

If you’re hoping to transform your skin into a smooth, supple state of bliss, this is the product you need. It contains aloe, bisabolol and conditioning emollients that your skin will love. And if you struggle with gel rinsing off in the shower while you shave, you’ll love the way this one stays on your skin from start to finish.

33. Shea Moisture Hi-Def Foamless Shave Gel

Shea Moisture Hi-Def Foamless Shave Gel will help you unlock a close, comfortable shave, free of razor bumps and burns. As you’ll see from the bottle and the name, this product contains tea tree oil and shea butter to condition and protect your skin for a slick, effortless shave anywhere on your body. It’s great for all skin types, but especially those with sensitive skin, as it is free from common irritants like parabens, sulfates, mineral oil, phthalates and propylene glycol.

34. Dove Rose Oil Body Wash Mousse

The Dove Rose Oil Body Wash Mousse and Shave Cream tandem works in two ways: It cleanses your skin, leaving it soft and conditioned, while serving as a shaving cream. With 100% gentle cleansers, this product offers a creamy, indulgent shower mousse that provides all-day nourishment. While it’s probably better suited for the women reading this list, we know some of the guys reading this article shave their bodies, and this would be a great choice for them.

35. Malin + Goetz Vitamin E Shaving Cream

Malin + Goetz is one of our favorite luxury skin-care and personal-grooming brands. Their Vitamin E Shaving Cream is an excellent choice for men and women alike. It’s lightweight and non-foaming, which makes shaving easy.

Plus, it helps protect your skin from abrasion and rinses clean, leaving behind no stains or residue. It won’t strip your skin of natural oils and works wonders for sensitive skin in particular as it’s free of harmful, harsh compounds.

36. Lather & Wood Shaving Soap

This premium, tallow-based shaving soap by Lather & Wood is an effective and unusual formula. A little goes a long way, making it an excellent budget option. No matter how you shave – straight razor, safety razor or multi-blade – this shaving soap will serve you well.

You can select from a range of incredible scents like Barbershop, Tobacco Rose, Clean Slate, Pacific Northwest and more. It’s handcrafted in small batches to ensure the highest quality possible.

37. Skintimate Raspberry Rain Shave Gel

This Skintimate Raspberry Rain Shave Gel is one of the best choices for women. This moisturizing shave gel smells remarkable and features six hydrating elements, including shea butter and vitamin E, to protect and replenish your skin’s natural moisture. It creates a creamy lather that aids in smooth razor glide for a close, comfortable shave and irresistibly touchable skin. It’s free from parabens, silicone and animal testing.

38. Ursa Major Natural Shave Cream

Ursa Major Natural Shave Cream features clean, cruelty-free ingredients that offer superb nourishing and shaving effects. Whether you’re shaving your legs, face or anything else, this concentrated non-lathering cream minimizes the occurrence of nicks and cuts while shielding your skin from razor burn. It naturally nourishes with ingredients like aloe, shea, willow bark, birch sap and sunflower. The fragrance provides hints of ginger, grapefruit, vetiver and bergamot.

39. Aesop Moroccan Neroli Shaving Serum

Last, but certainly not least, we want to showcase Aesop Moroccan Neroli Shaving Serum. This product isn’t cheap, but you get what you pay for. This formulation features a blend of hydrating botanicals to facilitate a close shave while calming and softening the skin.

It works well for all skin types and will leave your skin feeling smooth, calm and refreshed. We love the natural, holistic ingredients, which include sandalwood, neroli and panthenol. It has a woody, warm and spicy aroma that will make shaving a pleasure every time.

 

This article has been supplied by Verma Media, a paid advertiser. Content has not been independently verified by Los Angeles magazine.