Get Your Nog On: The 9 Eggnogs to Try in LA

Rum, bourbon, whiskey, scotch—these ‘nogs have it all.

Thanks to L.A.’s 70-degree winter days, one doesn’t immediately think of eggnog as the cocktail to enjoy during the holidays in SoCal. But if you are the traditional type where it’s just not the holidays without that rich cup of creamy, thick nog, you’re not going to let a little sunshine stop you. So for you, here are the best ones to try around town, ranging from the traditional to one topped with beer!

For a nog with a real foodie-pedigree, snatch up a bottle of “Big Daddy’s Baltimore Eggnog.” Handmade by Big Dave Lentz–aka Hungry Cat Chef David Lentz’s dad and AOC Chef Suzanne Goin’s father-in-law–this nog is from a 100-year-old family recipe. “My father gave me the original recipe over 40 years ago…every few years, I tweak it a little to my own satisfaction by changing alcoholic brands,” said Big Dave. Hungry Cat locations and Goin’s restaurants have been selling the family nog for several years and it started when Chef Lentz made his own and ran it as a drink special. His dad thought his was much better and they’ve been offering his version ever since. In this year’s batch Big Dave used Sailor Jerry’s spiced rum, Jameson Irish whiskey, and Christian Brothers’ brandy. You can pick up a 32-ounce bottle for $36 or you can stay and enjoy a glass for $10, while supplies last. (They plan to keep it in stock up to the New Year’s brunch.)

The Hollywood Roosevelt’s Spare Room has two different nog offerings by Beverage Director Naomi Schimek. The single serving “Nog in Sheep’s Clothing” is a rich mix of heavy cream, mulled demerara syrup, marsala, Sheep Dip Scotch, egg, and nutmeg. But, if you want a punch bowl-size nog for you and your crew while you bowl, there’s “Tonight at Noon” made with rum, amaro, eggs, sugar, cream, nutmeg, cinnamon, and garnished with a decadent espresso ice cream float. Order it up in advance with your reservation or for your private party.

For an umami bomb, drop by Feed Body & Soul in Venice for Matthew Biancaniello’s “Umami Milkshake” made with candy cap mushroom-infused Dancing Pines Bourbon, chanterelle-infused cream, egg, agave, and coffee shavings on top. This special holiday nog will be available til Christmas.

The Corner Door’s “Cousin Eddie” by bartender Beau du Bois is a combination of two family recipes with heavy cream, whole egg, white sugar, Armagnac, demerara rum, R. Jelinek Fernet, nutmeg, cinnamon, and black pepper. They’ll make these a la minute! And don’t fear the Fernet here, this Czech one is more approachable than the polarizing Fernet Branca.

Tasting Kitchen’s eggnog is made with cognac, aged Jamaican rum, and Amontillado sherry, “plus all the stuff that makes it rich and fatty–cream, milk, eggs, sugar, and nutmeg,” said barman Justin Pike. But be sure you have someone to tuck you in after drinking one.  “Last year my grandma drank a bunch when I wasn’t looking and had to go to bed at 6 p.m, on Christmas,” said Pike.

For an unexpected variation on the nog, try The Eveleigh’s Mezcal Eggnog by David Kupchinsky. It’s a smooth, smoky concoction of mezcal, Amantillado Sherry, cardamom, cream, eggs, and sugar that would be even better enjoyed by a fireplace.

At Craft in Century City, Beverage Director John Dal Canton infused Goslings Black Seal with candy cap mushrooms, dates and coffee and mixed it with Benedictine, a farm egg, cream, and Garam Masala. The result, which he calls “Jamaican Monk Flippin’ Out,” is a spicy fragrance on the nose and a flip that’s not too rich or eggy.

Dominick’s and Little Dom’s Beverage Director Nikki Sunseri has created a triad of unusual eggnog twists for December. There’s a Mint Julep Eggnog with fresh mint and Blanton’s bourbon; an Avocado Spice Eggnog with cinnamon/cardamom-infused cream, farmers market avocados, Tequila Ocho Reposado, and fresh grated cinnamon; or a Ginger Stout Eggnog of ginger/clove-steeped milk and topped with North Coast Old Rasputin Stout.

Goldie’s bartender Brittini Rae Peterson shamelessly stole her eggnog recipe from a cookbook she found in her grandmother’s house. But naturally, she put her own award-winning take on it. Her “Spiced & Malted Nog” is a festive mix of house spiced bourbon, Jamaican rum, milk, sugar, eggs, heavy cream, Nestle Carnation malted milk, vanilla, nutmeg, and Miracle Mile Chocolate Chili Bitters.