The DA’s Office Is No Longer Sending Representatives to Parole Hearings. A Rape Case Has People Questioning the Policy

Of the sweeping changes George Gasc贸n has made since taking office, this one might set off the biggest firestorm yet
612

Los Angeles County District Attorney George Gasc贸n came to the job promising sweeping changes, and so far he鈥檚 been true to his word. Since he took office in December, the new DA has instituted a dizzying number of changes from revoking cash bail to banning new death sentences, generating considerable controversy in the process. He recently came under fire from gay rights advocates for scrapping sentencing enhancements for hate crimes, and was rapped by his own deputy DAs for dismissing gang enhancements and firearm allegations from pending criminal proceedings. But it鈥檚 a change to the department鈥檚 parole procedures, quietly announced last December 7, that may set off the biggest firestorm yet.

For decades before Gasc贸n鈥檚 arrival, the prosecutor鈥檚 office routinely sent representatives to hearings to argue against early release of offenders. But Gasc贸n鈥檚 edict puts an end to that practice. Instead, the department鈥檚 new 鈥渄efault policy鈥 compels prosecutors to 鈥渟upport in writing the grant of parole鈥 for every person who has 鈥渁lready served their mandatory minimum period of incarceration.鈥 (If the person represents a 鈥渉igh鈥 risk for recidivism, the new policy says, prosecutors 鈥渕ay take a neutral position on the grant of parole.鈥)

Gasc贸n and other progressives argue that reflexive opposition to parole results in unjustifiably long prison sentences and does harm to communities.聽But the prosecutor鈥檚 absence from an upcoming parole hearing for a child rapist may be harder for him to defend. The case involves Ruben Beltran, a 46-year-old聽San Fernando Valley handyman and ex-Marine who was convicted in 2004 of sexually assaulting a brother and a sister, ages 8 and 6.

After serving 16 years of 15-to-life prison sentence, Beltran was up for parole in March. In December, the mother his two victims was one of the first Angelenos to learn that prosecutors are now barred from attending parole hearings. On December 8, the mother got a phone call from the deputy DA who had successfully prosecuted Beltran, informing her that the office will not be supporting the family at the upcoming parole hearing.

Stunned by the news, she called Gasc贸n, wrote letters to the L.A. County Board of Supervisors, and tried to hire a lawyer. Beltran, the mother said, insinuated himself into her and her children鈥檚 trust at a time when she and her husband were newly divorced.聽 鈥淭his isn鈥檛 someone who made a mistake,鈥 she told Los Angeles. 鈥淗e鈥檚 someone who appears to be very kind and loving but is calculating and vicious, and he can sense when someone is vulnerable.鈥

On January 21, at the victims鈥 request, Supervisor Kathryn Barger sent a letter to Gasc贸n asking him to make an exception in the Beltran case. 鈥淚 am concerned that this lack of representation for survivors, in this case and in others, will lead to more victimization among our residents,鈥 she wrote. As of January 31, neither she nor the victims鈥 mother had received a response.

Contacted by Los Angeles, Gasc贸n鈥檚 office declined to comment on the Beltran case, but Alex Bastian, a special advisor to the DA, noted in a written statement that the parole board has access to information on the offender that is more up to date and comprehensive than what is available to the prosecutor鈥檚 office, and thus board members are better equipped to 鈥渙bjectively determine whether someone is suitable for release.鈥

鈥淚f an individual seeking parole has not been rehabilitated, the parole board would correctly not find them suitable for release. In fact, more than 85 percent of the time, parole is denied,鈥 he said.聽鈥淗einous crimes against children are heart-wrenching and can leave victims and their families grief-stricken for life. That is exactly why the District Attorney is so focused on ensuring that our victims are provided trauma-informed services by our office鈥檚 Bureau of Victim Services.鈥

The outraged mother initially tried to hire her own attorney to represent her at the hearings, but couldn鈥檛 afford the expenses. Instead, she is getting legal help from a group of retired prosecutors who鈥檝e stepped in to advocate pro bono on behalf of victims at parole appearances. Anne Ingalls, a 30-year prosecutor who oversaw the Rampart scandal cases, is representing the family.聽Ingalls was motivated to get involved after the parole board granted a release date to a convicted murderer she successfully prosecuted in the 1990s. But, she says, the DA鈥檚 office is better positioned to help the victim prepare for the hearing because the prosecutor is the only party to have early access to the risk assessment report,聽the forensic psychologist鈥檚聽interview, and other documents about the inmate that no one else can obtain except the parole board or the defendant鈥檚 team. 鈥淎s her representative I would be pretty much operating in the dark,鈥 she admits. 鈥淚 could ask no questions to challenge or underline certain things said by the inmate聽which may show he is sanitizing his version of events聽or partially blaming the victim.

Already, the Beltran case has been taken up by right-wing activists who have been gunning for Gasc贸n. Just this week, Los Angeles County Sheriff Alex Villanueva announced that his department would begin sending representatives to parole hearings to give victims鈥 families 鈥渁 voice.鈥

In the Beltran case, at least, the furor may be premature. A few weeks before the hearing the parole board announced it was postponing the proceeding for 12 months to give the inmate and his defense team more time to prepare. The victims鈥 mother says the delay has given her more time to process the shock. 鈥淚t feels like a David and Goliath situation,鈥 she says. 鈥淎nd it鈥檚 not just going to affect me or my kids, it鈥檚 going to affect everybody in our position. The human cost of what Gasc贸n is doing is unbelievable.鈥


RELATED: DA George Gasc贸n Wanted to Scrap Hate Crimes Enhancements. LGBTQ Voters Fought Back


Stay on top of the latest in L.A. food and culture.聽Sign up for our newsletters today.