Foam Finger: The Los Angeles Angels Need to Pay Mike Trout What He’s Worth

Without a lucrative contract, the centerfielder could be wearing pinstripes in a couple of years

Mike Trout is 22 years old, and just the other day, the Los Angeles Angels centerfielder signed the highest non-arbitration one-year deal in the history of Major League Baseball for an even one million. Reports earlier in the week suggested the Angels were going to offer Trout something in the range of a six-year, $150 million contract. Now it’s likely the team will offer Trout that same six-year deal, or something similar, prior to the 2015 season, with Trout officially becoming a free agent at the age of 26 (in the event he isn’t signed to a max contract before then). I think he’s getting short-changed.

The centerfielder made his major-league debut for the Angels at the age of 19. His first two years were nothing short of spectacular. He won the American League’s Rookie of the Year award in 2012 and had another dazzling season in 2013, finishing second in the MVP voting for the second straight year. In fact, his wins above replacement during 2012—he produced at the plate while making catches like this look easy—brought him so close to MVP that the only other viable candidate was the Detroit Tigers’ Miguel Cabrera, the first player to win the triple crown since 1967. (Tough break, kid.)

If the offer matches the rumors, a free-agent Trout should most certainly walk for a better deal from a team willing to spend the cash. I’m no oracle, and it’s hard to rule out injury, deterioration, or a downward trend in performance, but with his skills, Trout can point to the salaries of his teammates when the time comes to negotiate. Two years ago, the Angels signed former St. Louis Cardinals great Albert Pujols to a 10-year, $240 million contract. So far, the investment hasn’t paid off. Pujols hit career lows in batting average, home runs, and RBIs last season, only playing 99 games due to a foot injury. Also, he isn’t getting any younger—he just turned 34 in January. Happy payday to you, Albert!

A year later, the Angels agreed to pay former Rangers slugger Josh Hamilton $125 million over five years, with similar results. Hamilton struck out 158 times last year, and batted a career-worst. That same year, the Angels renewed Trout’s contract with a $510,000 tender, an offer that his agent, Craig Landis, told the Los Angeles Times fell well short of “fair.”

Landis is absolutely right. Though Trout’s one-year deal is “historic,” it proves that the Angels are hesitant to pay up. And by continuing to flash his bat and glove this season, Trout is showing them how sorry they will be if they don’t reconsider—especially when Trout is wearing, oh I don’t know, pinstripes in 2018.