The Most Iconic Recipes from Classic L.A. Restaurants Revealed

The Cobb salad from the Brown Derby became iconic, the spicy tuna dip from Carlos ’n Charlie’s… not so much
131

In his new book L.A.’s Legendary Restaurants, chef George Geary pays homage to dozens of classic eating establishments with historic photos, artifacts, and recipes. More than 100 dishes from the golden age of Hollywood dining come to life via thoroughly researched formulas.

Clark Gable and Carole Lombard at the Hollywood Brown Derby 1938
Clark Gable and Carole Lombard at the Hollywood Brown Derby 1938

Photograph courtesy Marc Wanamaker/Bison Archives

Anybody who remembers (or wants to time travel to) the glory of Imperial Los Angeles of the mid 20th century will want to grab a bowl and start whipping up a batch of Hamburger Hamlet’s Onion Soup Fondue or that hot fudge sauce from C.C. Brown’s. I’m going to agree with the “legendary” label for those (not so much for specialties like the 1970s-era spicy tuna dip from Carlos ‘n Charlie’s on the Sunset Strip).

Schwab's Pharmacy in Hollywood
Schwab’s Pharmacy in Hollywood

Photograph courtesy of Marc Wanamaker/Bison Archives

The book augments impossibly rare photos of Walt Disney at the Tam O’Shanter, Lucy & Desi at the Brown Derby, and Orson Welles at Ma Maison, plus matchbooks, menus, and swizzle sticks sprinkled throughout that help make these old joints jump from the page.

Actor Hurd Hatfield and Angela Lansbury at Schwab's Pharmacy, 1945
Actor Hurd Hatfield and Angela Lansbury at Schwab’s Pharmacy, 1945

Photograph courtesy Marc Wanamaker/Bison Archives

The secret sauce is the collection of more than 100 recipes. A handful, including Miceli’s, Musso & Frank (does Clifton’s count?) still serve the famous dishes Geary teaches you how to make, but even if the restaurant is still open, you might not be served like your grandparents were. The recipe for the Mai Tai at the Formosa Café, for example, differs from the one currently served, which I’m more than a little hesitant to order. On a recent visit to the deflavorized dining room, someone in my party ordered a Navy Grog. The bartender stared at her slack jawed for a moment before sputtering “I literally have never heard of that. We mainly serve cheap beer.”

Geary went to great lengths to replicate the antique foodstuffs—with minor concessions (no MSG) to the contemporary palate. Geary discovered the formulas hidden in vintage food magazines, back issues of the Los Angeles Times, and rare cookbooks at Central Library. His test menu had to pass the memory test before they were included. Since there were multiple recipes for Chasen’s chili, and the author had never tried the original, that dish didn’t make the book.

Don the Beachcomber in Hollywood
Don the Beachcomber in Hollywood

Photograph courtesy of Marc Wanamaker/Bison Archives

Geary is the son of a Santa Monica carhop who has spent decades teaching, touring, and lecturing about the culinary arts. With stints ranging from cheesecake maker on The Golden Girls to making pastries for Disneyland, Geary is an expert in traditional American food and an master of bringing these long-gone favorites to life. If you’re a complete addict for these kinds of things, here’s the full list. Here are a few of our favorites from in the book.

Zombie from Don the Beachcomber
Zombie from Don the Beachcomber

Courtesy L.A.'S LEGENDARY RESTAURANTS by George Geary Santa Monica Press / October 2016

Cobb Salad from the Brown Derby
Cobb Salad from the Brown Derby

Courtesy L.A.'S LEGENDARY RESTAURANTS by George Geary Santa Monica Press / October 2016

Spicy Tuna Dip from Carlos 'n Charlie's
Spicy Tuna Dip from Carlos ‘n Charlie’s

Courtesy L.A.'S LEGENDARY RESTAURANTS by George Geary Santa Monica Press / October 2016

Hobo Steak from Chasen's
Hobo Steak from Chasen’s

Courtesy L.A.'S LEGENDARY RESTAURANTS by George Geary Santa Monica Press / October 2016

Hot Fudge Sauce from Schwab's Pharmacy
Hot Fudge Sauce from Schwab’s Pharmacy

Courtesy L.A.'S LEGENDARY RESTAURANTS by George Geary Santa Monica Press / October 2016

 

Facebook Comments